Joe Root’s frailties talk less about him and more about toxic English cricket culture

Joe Root’s frailties talk less about him and more about toxic English cricket culture

no photo

|

Getty

2013-14 was one of the worst periods in English cricket. Not only things plummeted massively as far as the team culture goes, but it was also the time they started losing some of their talented players who had helped them become a brute force in Tests, culminating with the No.1 ranking in 2011.

It was the time when the constant fight between Paul Downton - then director of cricket - and Kevin Pietersen played out in public and there was an abrupt ending to the romance that had started in 2005. It was fun until it lasted but why did it have to be that way? Pietersen was at the forefront of literally all the success that England had since the turn of the millennium but faced an unceremonious sacking. 

When England won their first Ashes series in almost two decades, Pietersen had scored a century. When England won their first global limited-overs trophy, Pietersen was Man of the Tournament. When England went on to secure the No.1 Test ranking with a 4-0 defeat over India, Pietersen led the way with a batting average of 106.60. And when England ensured one of the most difficult challenges India, Pietersen played the series-turning innings in Mumbai on a treacherous wicket - easily, one of the finest innings played by any overseas cricketer in India.

And justifiably, when the romance ended, the lingering aftertaste was sure to emerge. And it did. When the top-brass came forward to state that KP was responsible for a toxic team culture that affected the morale of the team, they forgot one simple fact the role of the management is to accept alternatives, diversity and imperfection while preserving a genius with a deal that would make both sides winners, albeit in a short-term basis. However, as things stood, they decided to clean the debris - as they thought it was, and actually it might have been in reality - and it was no coincidence that England ended up having a massive crisis of sorts parallelly. The signs were ominous.

Almost at the same time, Steve Finn was left to do his soul-searching while an overused Graeme Swann decided to call it a day, simply because of the fact he couldn’t accommodate himself with the rigours of Test schedule, while Jonathan Trott, after being bruised by Mitchell Johnson, took time out and eventually fell apart in the international circuit. Most significantly, the likes of Alastair Cook and Joe Root had also lost their form and the perils of it are still felt in English cricket.

That, Joe Root is struggling, and as a matter of fact, nowhere close to what had put him as one of the leading batsmen in Test cricket should tell a story. It has been a particularly long summer of cricket in the United Kingdom, and Root has been one of the few constants in all three formats of the team. He was there against India, turned up for Sydney Thunder in Big Bash League, came back to play against Sri Lanka and Windies before turning up for all the games in the World Cup and now marshalling the troupe in the all-important Ashes. 

This tells a story about how England and Wales Cricket Board failed to learn anything from the Trott or more recently, Cook fiasco. After turning up for no less than consecutive 159 Tests, only at the age of 33, the former English skipper decided to call it a day because the spirit was waning. Looking at Joe Root, it seems like history is laughing at English cricket. 

What could be the possible repercussions of it or was it because the World Cup added the extra mileage which messed up the workload management, especially because the Ashes was unavoidable? When the English skipper came for the press conference before The Oval Test, the answer was written all over his face. Then he decided to speak about it. “It’d be wrong to say I’m not. It’s been 10 weeks of hard cricket, high emotions, ups and downs, and it does take a lot out of you.” 

“It’d be wrong to say I’m not. It’s been 10 weeks of hard cricket, high emotions, ups and downs, and it does take a lot out of you.”

Joe Root, ahead of The Oval Test

A rest might make things up and he might get his mojo back, but this also tells a very difficult tale about the English team. And for that, I will again go back to the last phase of Jonathan Trott’s career. He had a disastrous tour of Australia, where Mitchell Johnson made him suffer to no end, but the cricket anorak that Trott was, he must have felt he could bounce back in West Indies. However, when he was dismissed in the second innings of that final Test in Barbados, everything seemed like a torment and Brisbane public humiliation followed. 

The only thing that had kept him going in his life - batting - was no more his ally and he didn’t have anything to fall back on. For one of England’s greatest fighters in red-ball cricket, the tragic became a reality because the edge was gone and so was the fun element. I would quote another factoid here. In the five years of his Test career, Swann bowled 2,558 overs and as a matter of fact, outside of his own team, there wasn’t a bowler anywhere in the world who even came close to that. Who took the blame for it? 

English cricket, more than any other, has suffered the most because of depression but the fear factor of talking about it resulted in some of the talents frittering away to oblivion. The likes of Alan Mullaly, Steve Harmison, Monty Panesar, Trott, Andrew Flintoff, Steve Davies, Tim Ambrose, Matthew Hoggard, and Michael Yardy – and the list is unending – had some of the promising careers but ended in a way that was sad, to say the least. 

Shouldn’t England learn from the same now and ensure a level playing field for its players to express themselves on the field and have fun on the beaches with their family or least, grab a bottle of beer in their own dining hall and talk about the good things with his wife and parents? It is highly doubtful that the current scheduling allows any players any downtime. 

From the looks of it, it doesn’t seem like it was going to happen in the next couple of years too, or even beyond that. ECB prepare themselves for "The Hundred", which is going to debut at the same time as the domestic 50-over competition, and given the stance that the board has taken amidst all opposition to the newly-found format, it would be surprising if any star English players stay away from it. Considering all the above factors, don’t be surprised if England keep falling down in Test cricket, although it is completely possible that they could pick themselves up. As was in Trott’s case, the signs are ominous for the current English cricket team too.  

Get updates! Follow us on

Open all