What if Wednesday | What if Brendon McCullum never captained New Zealand

What if Wednesday | What if Brendon McCullum never captained New Zealand

no photo

|

SportsCafe

On March 31 2015, Brendon McCullum's New Zealand team were received at home as heroes despite their World Cup final defeat, in Melbourne, at the hands of Australia. That’s how much the people were taken by the ‘Baz’ era that changed their cricket forever, but what if Baz never happened to them?

Brendon McCullum, who made his debut in 2002, had captained the team before 2013 but only became a full-fledged captain in that year after Ross Taylor was unceremoniously removed from that position. Little did Mike Hesson, the maker of these decisions, know that his action would turn out to be one of the greatest things that ever happened to New Zealand cricket. But what if Ross Taylor remained the captain of the New Zealand team and Brendon McCullum remained as it is and the ‘Baz’ era never happened? 

The year is 2012 and Stephen Fleming is long gone, New Zealand is still struggling to find a captain who sticks and wins games for them. Well, Ross Taylor is the most passionate about the role when compared to his peers- Daniel Vettori and Brendon McCullum. But the newly appointed coach, Mike Hesson, isn’t too keen on having Taylor continue his captaincy run. And why not? After all, New Zealand had a terrible year under Taylor losing series after series to the Windies, South Africa and Sri Lanka. Hesson, the man manager, was only looking for wins. To make a team that doesn’t succumb to pressure situations. He has a talk with New Zealand Cricket and Ross Taylor has been stripped of captaincy right ahead of the South Africa tour. Taylor, a long-serving cricketer of the BlackCaps, is infuriated by the decision. The Samoan decides to go on an exile and the team flies to South Africa next while McCullum is captain through natural selection. 

Things have worsened for the visitors, who only managed a total of 45 in the first innings of the series opener, and lost both Tests by a margin of an innings and more. Meanwhile, Martin Crowe - who had burned his New Zealand team blazer after Taylor was made to step down as captain- has now made some calls to the board and has scheduled a meeting with Hesson. From all the media got to know, the meeting has ended in favour of Taylor and he is being called back to join the squad. The seasoned batsman has made it clear that he will only return if he is named captain again. But at the end of the chaos, Taylor has been reinstated as the skipper across all formats. New Zealand are back home after a horrendous tour and England are visiting them. 

All eyes are on Taylor and how the new era of Taylor-Hesson turns out for New Zealand. Next, the hosts have won the series opener convincingly and McCullum (69*), at the end of the game, speaks of how the captaincy burden being taken off has helped him grow as a player. Meanwhile, a certain Kane Williamson at No.3, awarded the Man of the March for his 74, shows the kind of promise the team had been looking for. Taylor and Hesson, at the press conference, have made it clear that they are building a team that will do wonders in the long run and that is not a dark horse in every ICC tournament. 

Suddenly, some drastic changes are being made to the side. The team wasn’t doing wonders in any format as such but the individual promise that the youngsters were showing was massive. After a barren run, Kyle Mills and James Franklin have been left out of the squad that toured the UAE in late 2014. Meanwhile, Daniel Vettori has made his intentions of coming back public. However, from the looks of it, New Zealand are not turning to the seniors anymore. Instead, a red-ball specialist Trent Boult has been made regular and talks are that he will partner Tim Southee in the upcoming World Cup. It’s 14 December 2014, a lanky slow left-arm orthodox is delivering for the Kiwis in the middle overs. No, it isn’t Vettori, it’s a certain Mitchell Santner from Hamilton in his early 20s playing the third ODI of his career. 

Santner’s name was all over, as Vettori was on an exile with no signs of return, being called as Hamilton’s Vettori after a great domestic season. Now the turn he produces, at Sharjah, has the centurion Ahmed Shehzad all bamboozled as the bails behind him are off. At the end of the game, that New Zealand lost despite Williamson’s ton and debutant Henry Nicholls’ half-century, Taylor said that the management have pretty much finalised the bowling department are ready to take the risk with a rather new-look team. As far as the batting is concerned, a final call will be taken during the seven-match long Sri Lanka series at home. 

It’s February 2015, a day of love and a special day for cricket fans as the World Cup kicks off, and New Zealand are facing Sri Lanka at Christchurch. Ross Taylor is living his dreaming of leading the side in a World Cup. Signs are promising for New Zealand, who won the toss and have Martin Guptill in the form of his life. Guptill had just scored three centuries against Sri Lanka, while Tom Latham’s poor form had Brendon McCullum back as a regular and Henry Nicholls had to bat down the order. Both openers started whacking the Lankan attack from ball one. The game, which the hosts won by 102 runs, saw Boult-Southee-Santner bagging three each with one run out caused by Jimmy Neesham whose all-rounder abilities had denied Grant Elliot a spot in the squad. What stands at the end of the next five weeks, New Zealand have won all home games except one - against Australia. 

However, they still remain the Group A toppers and are now supposed to meet South Africa- who managed four wins in six group games with AB de Villiers in a form better than ever. Guptill started off brilliantly but it’s Williamson who has amassed 497 runs in six games, while Taylor has had an on and off run. Neesham and his cameos had set the stage on fire while McCullum’s power-hitting took a back seat. So the action begins in Auckland, on March 24 2015, between the two teams who have never played a World Cup final before.

AB de Villiers, unbeaten at 170, has smacked all the Kiwi bowlers and put up a target of 310 for New Zealand to chase. The top-order gives a great start to the Kiwis but rain comes in and the target is revised to 281 off 43 overs. The hosts have to score 50 more runs in four overs with five wickets remaining. Williamson, on his way to another hundred, starts firing. But while coming down on one foot to whip one over long-on, he falls prey to JP Duminy landing a safe catch. As a result, wickets keep tumbling down as Jimmy Neesham (34 off 19*) watches from the other end and suddenly 14 runs are required off the last over, with Dale Steyn on the attack. Neesham has denied two singles to keep Boult away from the strike. 

He sent one to the square leg boundary and followed it with a swift cover drive. With six runs still required off the final three deliveries, Neesham was bamboozled by two consecutive yorkers by the great Dale Steyn. On the final delivery, New Zealand still requiring six runs, Neesham went for the big one but the fielder at long-on, Duminy, landed a catch that shattered New Zealand’s dreams of making it to the final for the seventh time in World Cup history. Steyn walked to Neesham, kneeling on the ground with his head down, and consoled him.  

The New Zealand cricket team were, once again, nobody(s) at their own home. The semifinal jinx was never to be broken. However, Hesson was vocal about still building a team around the same individuals, the youngsters with Taylor as the leader of the pack. New Zealand followed England’s footsteps into moving on from the World Cup exit and creating their strongest of sides in history. Soon, McCullum couldn’t keep up with the rest of the team with just his cameos and announced his retirement. Tom Latham was called back into the squad and Nicholls was promoted as an opener. Taylor enjoyed a run of six unbeaten series at home before they toured India in 2017. Together, Nicholls-Taylor-Latham-Williamson thrashed India 3-0 in the subcontinent and the Kiwis have now been declared as a force. Eventually, they are the favourites to lift the 2019 World Cup besides the hosts, England. 

It’s July 14 2019, the crowd at Lord’s will be witnessing a new World Champion today. Taylor and Latham with the bat and Boult and Matt Henry had bulldozed India in the semifinals to reach the final at Lords, New Zealand’s first. Before history is made, Eoin Morgan and Ross Taylor meet at the toss and the Kiwi wins it to opt to bowl first. Lockie Ferguson, a revelation, bagged four wickets with Santner picking up three to restrict the hosts to a total of 241 in 50 overs. While Guptill was dismissed early in the chase, Nicholls stood his ground and formed a 77-run partnership with Williamson. When Ross Taylor walked in, the Kiwis were on 101/2 (30.5 overs). Taylor kept it slow and let others bat around him. With New Zealand’s fourth dismissal, Neesham joined the action. He did not have to bat in the semifinal but the memories of the 2015 semifinal still haunted him, as he tweeted last night. 

Taylor had barely survived an lbw decision against him, by Marius Erasmus, when batting on 15. The seniormost Kiwi had already announced that irrespective of the result, he will hand over the captaincy to Williamson who is ready to take charge. Both Neesham and Taylor had a huge milestone in front of them, their final chance to get things right. Taylor continued taking it slow, while Neesham greeted everyone starting from Jofra Archer to Mark Wood with an occasional boundary. At the start of the 45th over, Archer came in to bowl his 9th, and only seven runs were required. Taylor, on strike, took a single off the first delivery and passed it on to his partner. Neesham stepped out and launched a six over the mid-wicket fence to win New Zealand their first-ever World Cup trophy! 

Finally, finaaaalllyyy, New Zealand had made their biggest dream of embracing a WORLD CUP come true! The ever-so-stubborn Ross Taylor made his six years of struggle finally count. In this universe, Neesham’s SIX won the BlackCaps their maiden World Cup!

Get updates! Follow us on

Open all