Twitter divided with opinions after R Ashwin demands free ball for batsmen backing up

Twitter divided with opinions after R Ashwin demands free ball for batsmen backing up

no photo

Ashwin effects Mankad dismissal

|

Twitter

After Ravichandran Ashwin suggested the idea of a free ball, former cricketers like WV Raman and Rohan Gavaskar have thrown their support to Ashwin, calling batsmen to stay inside the crease. However, few like Venky Mysore holds a different viewpoint calling such dismissal harsh on batsmen.

After Ricky Ponting triggered the Spirit of Cricket debate by revealing that he would have a hard conversation with Ravichandran Ashwin regarding his view on Mankading, Dinesh Karthik came back with a reply that the debate itself falls on the grey area and stated that it is unfair to link the dismissal to the spirit of the game or call it ‘Mankading’ as it is permitted by laws of the game.

Ashwin then replied back by saying, “Make it a free ball for the bowler. If the batsmen get out of that ball, the batting team will be docked 5 runs. Free hit adds to the drama for a batter, let’s give a chance to the bowlers too.”

Quite an innovative decision, Ashwin made his point quite succinctly and rightfully so, he garnered support from many former cricketers. WV Raman quoted dialogue from ‘The Good, the Bad and the Ugly’ to say, “Echoing the famous line of Eli Wallach, ‘when you have to shoot, shoot, don’t talk’. Similarly, ‘when you have to stay in the crease, stay in, don’t walk out’,” Raman said.

Rohan Gavaskar reiterated the same sentiment that if a batsman backing up is within the spirit of the game, then how come, someone doing the right thing as per the rules of the game can be challenged. 

“I think ‘spirit of the game’ is so vague. Is it in the spirit of the game to not walk when one knows he/she is out or to appeal to dismiss a batter when one knows he/ she is not out? It’s not – yet that is accepted and practised by nearly everybody. My feeling is that more bowers don’t do it because of the backlash that it creates …the negative publicity and the drama,” Rohan added.

Kolkata Knight Riders CEO Venky Mysore, however, has a viewpoint that Mankading is a “harsh” dismissal and cricket bodies should look to dock runs for batsmen backing up. Harsha Bhogle added that the rule should be made simple and subjectiveness should be taken off the block.

“Rules vs. spirit cannot settle the issue. To me, Mankading dismissal is too harsh & jarring to everyone. So change rule? Reduce a run like in the case of ‘one short’? Would that be fair?,” Mysore tweeted.

“I think the rule should be simple and take away any subjective element like ‘normal delivery position’ and just say ‘non-striker stays in till the ball is released’,” Bhogle added after that.

Get updates! Follow us on

Open all