While traditionally a night watchman is supposed to guard the wicket until the end of the play, to which there were just three minutes at the time, McCullum's philosophy advocates batters to show intent no matter what. Broad, facing debutant Kuggeleijn who had already scalped Crawley on the fourth ball of the over, danced down the track attempting a wild pull shot on his first delivery. However, the ball clattered into his body with no damage. Unrelenting, Scott chose the short ball again and Broad heaved at it one more, only to find a thick top edge to send the ball soaring high into the night sky. The catch seemed to be a foregone conclusion as four fielders converged, primarily the bowler and wicket-keeper Tom Blundell. 

However, as the ball descended, Scott screamed and urged at the keeper to go for the catch given he had the gloves on. Yet, Blundell suffered a very evident brain freeze, thereby halting in his tracks and letting the opportunity slip. The incident drew a hilarious reaction from the English dressing room as the players on the balcony could not help clapping and laughing. Blundell was simply left embarrassed and covered his face with his hand, thereby capping off what the commentators labelled an 'absolute classic' amidst much laughter and banter.