Ashes | Twitter reacts as Gaffney blindly follows nonsensical Snicko to ludicrously rule Smith out
When Australia and England combine to criticize something, it is probably time to make do with. After two huge gaffes, Snicko surpassed all parameters of reliability with a third that defied logic, with victim Jamie Smith not even bothering to protest considering just how absurd the decision was.
Australia practically sealed the Ashes in their favour on Day 2 of the Adelaide Test after running through England's batting unit in double quick time after posting 371 on the board batting first. While player of the series to date Mitchell Starc endured a rare quiet day with the ball, the rest of the cartel more than made up for it with leading acts from returning men Pat Cummins and Nathan Lyon. Keeping aside the hosts' disciplined bowling effort, the visitors' batting left a lot to be desired as batsmen once again fell to some poor shot selection. Technology did not aide their cause either, as it returned to haunt them during their batting effort a day after it had allowed Alex Carey to incorrectly survive which culminated in a potentially match-winning ton for the wicket-keeper. Unfortunately for Jamie Smith, the exact opposite fate awaited him.
Controversy was already rife after Smith blatantly gloved a Cummins bumper to slip but Chris Gaffaney with the help of Snicko ruled the ball had actually struck his helmet, albeit it was all moot considering Usman Khawaja had failed to grab onto the catch cleanly. Nevertheless, in Cummins' very next over, the Aussie skipper went short again and Smith tried to pull him square but went through with his shot too early and the ball skid through past his underedge. However, as soon as Carey pocketed the ball he went up in appeal, seeing which Cummins raised his hands too albeit with a confused look on his face. Quickly enough the entire team joined in, and the umpires decided to take the safe route by sending the decision upstairs under the guise of checking for a fair catch. Replays showed that Carey had caught the Kookaburra well above the ground, and whether there was bat involved remained the only question between survival and dismissal for Smith. The Snicko showed a significant spike a couple of frames after the ball had passed the bat by some distance, with at least a couple of inches between the willow and the red cherry at the point of the sound's incidence. Even so, Gaffaney culd not ignore the spike that had showed up, and ruled Smith out without much explanation.
Smith was stunned for a brief moment, before he hung his head and walked off quietly, his discomfort with the decision well echoed by Twitterati.
How!???
— Usman mohammed (@Usmanmoham35703) December 18, 2025
Hilarious!
Labuschagne said
— lucy cuzzupe (@LCuzzupe) December 18, 2025
Snicko needs to be sack
love that stump mic
😂🏏#Ashes
Process Gone Wrong
This is bullshit with these umpire reviews, honestly! #Ashes
— Andrew Young (@andrewy181993) December 18, 2025
Waiting!
Ben stokes going to show his beast mode today 💯 loading#Ashes#BenStokes
— MR (@IamManu_45) December 18, 2025
What?!!
— Usman mohammed (@Usmanmoham35703) December 18, 2025
Process Matters
I know it's silly checking snicko after seeing the ball bounce, but the umpires have to follow their process don't they #Ashes
— Harrison (@RollTruTV) December 18, 2025
Lol!
"snicko needs to be sacked"🤣#Ashes #Ausvseng pic.twitter.com/dNnlos7BAv
— W (@Gowtham_sfc_) December 18, 2025
Umpiring Disaster
This has to be the worst third umpiring I have ever seen.
— gigacoded (@gigacoded) December 18, 2025
That ball almost below Jamie Smith's glove off 😂#ashes
Tech Trouble
Wouldn't want shares in Snicko this week #Ashes
— Kelsinator (@kelsinator) December 18, 2025
Haha!
Snicko operating on Adelaide time. 30mins behind. #Ashes2025
— Adam Place (@therockbreaker1) December 18, 2025
Snicko Chaos
Snicko is making a mockery of this match.
— Captain Nookie (@captainnookie) December 18, 2025
Comments
Leave a comment0 Comments